If you are actively discerning a vocation to the Priesthood, Diaconate, Consecrated Life, or Marriage and you are looking for information to help in your discernment, BE SURE TO CHECK the section at the bottom of the right sidebar for the "labels" on all posts. By clicking on one of these labels it will take you to a page with all posts containing that subject. You will also find many links for suggested reading near the bottom of the right sidebar. Best wishes and be assured of my daily prayers for your discernment.

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

The Church’s Religious Life

From First Things
Posted by Ryan T. Anderson on February 5, 2008
(Emphases mine)

The Drudge Report is highlighting this BBC article on the decline of religious life in the Catholic Church. Here’s the basic gist:

Newly published statistics showed that the number of men and women belonging to religious orders fell by 10% to just under a million between 2005 and 2006.

During the pontificate of the late Pope John Paul II, the number of Catholic nuns worldwide declined by a quarter.

The downward trend accelerated despite a steady increase in the membership of the Catholic Church to more than 1.1bn.

However, correspondents say even this failed to keep pace with the overall increase in world population.

I’ve often wondered what the decline in religious life has meant for the average Catholic. Personally, I can count the number of religious sisters and brothers that I know on one hand–and this includes people I met growing up in Baltimore, attending college and then working in Princeton, and now living and working in Manhattan. If I include diocesan priests (technically “secular”), the number jumps up, but even then it’s fair to say that I don’t really “know” most of the priests who have administered the sacraments to me. If push came to shove, there would probably be a couple priests from college and New York who, in a time of trouble, I’d feel comfortable going to see. My parents experienced something different. They, of course, went to Catholic schools all their life, were taught by religious brothers and sisters, and still have vivid memories of the relationships that were forged–relationships that secured them in the faith. One wonders what the loss of religious witness and a ministry of presence has meant to the Church simply on a person-to-person level.

Of course times change. Renewal movements in the Church have opened new possibilities for Christian vocation and holiness in ordinary life. People who might have joined religious communities in times past now find themselves involved with groups like Communion and Liberation, Opus Dei, Regnum Christi, Focolare, and the Neo-Catechumenal Way–all providing lay people with models, organizational supports, and what certainly seem to some like lay vocations. The members of these groups say that a rising tide lifts all ships and a general increase in holiness in the Church will–and, according to their experience, already has–led to priestly and religious vocations. If they’re right, and they likely are, one shudders to think how much more drastic the decline in religious life would be if the renewal movements didn’t exist.

Some will argue that the Church doesn’t need robust religious communities, especially not the ones in monasteries and convents. It’s no longer the Middle Ages, and the Catholic Church doesn’t need to sustain Western culture behind the walls of the Carmel. So much for contemplative life–and the prayers that sustain the Church. The active religious communities? Well, they’re fine and good, but can’t we leave this social work to professional social workers? And in light of the feminist movement, can’t women aspire to something more than soothing bed sores in Calcutta? Somehow the personal witness of a life radically devoted to Christ in loving service to others seems radically discounted.

Yet the institutional loss has been no less severe. And here my mind immediately jumps to some of the most pressing needs daunting contemporary society: decent education for those who can’t afford it; food, drink, shelter and assistance to independence for the homeless; health care for those whose salaries can just meet their bare necessities like rent, heating and electricity, and groceries. One wonders if the state will ever be able to meet these needs–let alone the need for personal care and human love. Maybe the charitable activities of the Church alone will suffice. What would happen to our inner cities if Catholic schools, hospitals, soup kitchens and shelters shut down? But the sad reality is that many of them depend on governmental moneys. When the Church had a ready supply of celibate religious–without the need to earn a wage to provide for a family, with the freedom to give themselves completely to their ministry, and expecting (even vowing) a life of poverty–staffing Catholic schools and Catholic hospitals was much easier.

The situation isn’t entirely bleak. One is forced to think about communities like the Nashville Dominican sisters, or the Sisters of Life, or the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal–youthful, vibrate, orthodox, flourishing communities. Maybe they’re the future of religious life.

I’m just thinking out loud, and I’m rambling, so I’ll stop here. But maybe this Lent a prayer intention should be for an increase in vocations to religious life.


Edward said...

In just about every diocese in the world, the Catholic faith and its traditions have been replaced by a novel modernist religion dominated by neo-marxism. Reference Bishop Marini's new book for verification of this fact. As evidenced by Bishop Marini and his minions, the Left no longer even attempt to hide the fact that they hijacked Vatican II, invented their vision of Vatican II (aka its "Spirit"), and applied the "Spirit" with a sledge hammer throughout the entire Catholic world.

The decline of vocations and the near universal loss of faith amongst the laity is the fruit of their efforts. One could infer from their own words that this effect was there intent all along.

Instead of praying for vocations this lent, maybe we should pray for our Pope that he may continue to be successful in his efforts to restore the Church's faith and traditions. Conversion of Catholics to the Catholic faith and an increase of vocations to Holy Mother Church will only come after the Church is restored.

May Pope Benedict XVI reign forever.

Anonymous said...

Can't we do both?

Fr. David Streit, SVD said...

"Young, vibrant, orthodox, flourishing communities" aren't the only ones blessed by God.

The Society of the Divine Word (Divine Word Missionaries - SVD) is probably not considered 'orthodox' enough by some traditional Catholics since we don't wear habits.

But we are one of the largest men's congregations in the Church. We didn't 'crash and burn' after Vatican II. John Paul II canonized 2 SVDs and beatified 5. The cause of 19 more is underway.

We number 6,138, up from 5,826 in 1998. 347 novices this year, and more than 1,100 in temporal vows. Asians and Africans make up more than half of the congregation. We are from 69 countries and work in more than 70 contries on all continents. 51 SVDs are now Bishops. Our average age is about 48 and going down. Anywhere between 90 and 140 profess final vows and receive mission appointments each year.

God has blessed us and continues to bless us. We may not wear habits, but we do preach the Word made Flesh and work to build up the local Church from Siberia to Patagonia.

"By virtue of our vow we owe obedience to the Pope as the highest ecclesiastical superior of the Society" (Constitution 609).

Whose definition of 'orthodox' do we have to meet in order to be considered a religious order to which one can safely recommend young people thinking of the religious and missionary life?

Brad Watkins said...

Fr. Streit,

Thank you for your post. I wanted to highlight the fact that this particular post is copied from the 'First Things' blog - I did not write it. Emphases however is mine. It was certainly not my intention to discount the growth of other communities or question their orthodoxy. I do think it is important to highlight that the growth in religious communities in the United States does trend towards those that are young, habited, and unflinchingly faithful to the Magisterium. Some would certainly describe them as orthodox or traditional. None of these communities have foundations in Africa or Asia.

Thank for bringing your community to my attention. Truth be told, I had never heard of it before.

Yours in Christ,
Brad Watkins

Edward said...

I was curious, so I googled the Society of the Divine Word and found this link:


Peruse the website and make up your own mind as to how "orthodox" this order is. I will keep my opinions to myself.